Sign in

You're signed outSign in or to get full access.

CM

COMPASS MINERALS INTERNATIONAL INC (CMP)·Q4 2024 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • Q4 2024 revenue fell 11% year over year to $208.8M; adjusted EBITDA was $15.6M, and diluted EPS was $(1.17), reflecting a mild winter and a $17.6M water rights impairment in Plant Nutrition .
  • Salt pricing rose 10% while volumes fell 21%; Salt adjusted EBITDA was $38.1M with strong price/mix but lower prefill, and adjusted EBITDA per ton increased to $25.2 as highlighted on the call .
  • FY2025 guidance: Salt volumes +~9% vs FY2024 mid-point, total adjusted EBITDA $169–$209M, capex $100–$110M; committed highway deicing prices down ~2% and commitments down ~9% vs prior bid season .
  • Management is prioritizing cash generation, inventory drawdowns, cost control (including Goderich curtailment) and plans to refinance the debt stack for more covenant flexibility—key stock catalysts hinge on winter severity and execution of structural efficiency projects .

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

What Went Well

  • Salt segment maintained pricing power: Q4 Salt pricing up 10% year over year with total average price/ton $107.66 despite weaker volumes; adjusted EBITDA per ton rose to ~$25.2 in the quarter and ~$24.50 for FY2024 .
  • Plant Nutrition volumes recovered: Q4 volumes +33% year over year to 68k tons, echoing demand normalization after last year’s unusual weather; revenue +20% year over year .
  • Clear strategic focus and operational initiatives: “back to basics” refocus on Salt and Plant Nutrition and targeted projects (Goderich mill relocation/East Mains, Ogden pond restoration) to lower cost structure and improve cash generation .

Direct quotes:

  • “We made the important strategic decision to get ‘back to basics’ by refocusing on our core Salt and Plant Nutrition businesses... focus on improving the cash generation capability across our platform and reducing our absolute levels of indebtedness...” — CEO Ed Dowling .
  • “My goal... is to gear the company such that it generates free cash flow even in mild winters, strong free cash flow in normal winters and outstanding free cash flow in strong winters.” — CEO Ed Dowling .

What Went Wrong

  • Mild winter dragged results: consolidated operating loss $(29.8)M and net loss $(48.3)M; Salt volumes down 21% year over year due to muted prefill activity, impacting Q4 results .
  • Plant Nutrition impairment and profitability: Q4 included a $17.6M water rights impairment; adjusted EBITDA declined to $(3.7)M and average price/ton fell 10% year over year to $623 amid broader potash price pressure .
  • Corporate headwinds and leverage: FY2024 included $191.0M in non-cash impairments (Lithium, Fortress, Plant Nutrition); net leverage was 4.9x at year-end (within covenant), underscoring balance sheet constraints .

Financial Results

Consolidated Results vs Prior Year, Prior Quarter, and Estimates

Note: S&P Global Wall Street consensus estimates were unavailable at time of analysis; comparison to estimates not provided.

MetricQ4 2023Q3 2024Q4 2024
Revenue ($USD Millions)$233.6 $202.9 $208.8
Diluted EPS ($)$(0.10) $(1.05) $(1.17)
Adjusted EBITDA ($USD Millions)$31.3 $32.8 $15.6
Operating Margin (%)0.9% 2.9% (14.3)%
Adjusted Operating Margin (%)0.9% 3.6% (6.1)%
Consensus RevenueN/AN/AN/A
Consensus EPSN/AN/AN/A

Segment Breakdown

MetricQ4 2023Q3 2024Q4 2024
Salt Sales ($USD Millions)$186.7 $160.6 $162.5
Salt Adjusted EBITDA ($USD Millions)$44.2 $41.6 $38.1
Plant Nutrition Sales ($USD Millions)$35.3 $38.8 $42.4
Plant Nutrition Adjusted EBITDA ($USD Millions)$5.0 $7.2 $(3.7)

KPIs

KPIQ4 2023Q3 2024Q4 2024
Salt Total Sales Volumes (000s tons)1,905 1,483 1,510
Salt Total Avg Price/ton ($)$98.03 $108.27 $107.66
Salt Highway Deicing Volumes (000s tons)1,435 1,090 1,061
Salt Highway Deicing Avg Price/ton ($)$68.78 $77.20 $70.98
Plant Nutrition Volumes (000s tons)51 56 68
Plant Nutrition Avg Price/ton ($)$691 $691.27 $623
Salt Adjusted EBITDA/ton ($)N/AN/A$25.2
Liquidity ($USD Millions)N/AN/A$189.9
Net Leverage (x)N/AN/A4.9x

Guidance Changes

MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent GuidanceChange (raised/lowered/maintained)
Salt Total Sales Volumes (000s tons)FY2025N/A9,650–10,700 N/A
Salt Revenue ($USD Millions)FY2025N/A$940–$1,040 N/A
Salt Adjusted EBITDA ($USD Millions)FY2025N/A$225–$250 N/A
Plant Nutrition Volumes (000s tons)FY2025N/A285–305 N/A
Plant Nutrition Revenue ($USD Millions)FY2025N/A$175–$195 N/A
Plant Nutrition Adjusted EBITDA ($USD Millions)FY2025N/A$14–$20 N/A
Corporate Adjusted EBITDA ($USD Millions)FY2025N/A($70)–($61) N/A
Total Adjusted EBITDA ($USD Millions)FY2025N/A$169–$209 N/A
Capex ($USD Millions)FY2025N/A$100–$110 N/A
Interest Expense, net ($USD Millions)FY2025N/A$67–$72 N/A
DD&A ($USD Millions)FY2025N/A$105–$115 N/A
Effective Tax Rate (excl. valuation allowance)FY2025N/A(295%)–(290%) N/A
Dividend PolicyOngoingBoard determined not to declare dividends for foreseeable future Ongoing suspension Maintained (suspension)
Salt Total Sales Volumes (000s tons)FY20249,200–9,400 Actual: 9,314 N/A (actual reported)
Salt Adjusted EBITDA ($USD Millions)FY2024$200–$210 Actual: $228.2 Outperformed guidance (FY24 guide $200–$210 ; actual $228.2 )

Additional FY2025 context:

  • Highway deicing: average contract price down ~2% and committed volumes down ~9% vs prior bid season .
  • Company expects ~75% of highway deicing sales in H1 FY2025 .

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

TopicPrevious Mentions (Q2 2024, Q3 2024)Current Period (Q4 2024)Trend
Strategy refocus, cash generationQ2: “back to basics”; dividend suspension; Goderich curtailment to harvest cash; SG&A program Reinforced focus on cash generation; inventory reduction; flexible production; free cash flow goal across winter scenarios Continuing execution
Salt pricing/mix and volumesQ2: Pricing up; volumes down due to mild winter; adjusted EBITDA margin +200 bps Q4: Pricing +10%; volumes −21% YoY; adjusted EBITDA/ton highlighted Price/mix resilient; volumes weather-dependent
Goderich mill relocation/East MainsQ2: Under evaluation within capital prioritization framework Q4: Detailed benefits (access, ventilation, lower ground control costs) and project underway Advancing with clear benefits
Plant Nutrition pond restoration/KCl usageQ2: Leadership changes; cost focus; goodwill impairment Q4: Pond restoration, KCl utilization to reduce harvest demands; aiming to lower all-in costs Operational improvements expected
Fortress (fire retardant)Q2: USFS uncertainty; impairments; evaluating alternatives Q4: Negotiations continue; alternate non-MgCl product under consideration; no revenue in guidance Cautious; option value
Balance sheet, covenants, refinancingQ2: Amended credit agreement for covenant relief Q4: Plan to refinance into more covenant-light structure in 2025 Positive intent, execution pending
Winter timing/pre-fill behaviorQ2: Weak winter (second worst in 27 years) Q4: Pre-fill muted; discussion of possible shift of winter into calendar Q1/Q2 and sales-to-commitment ratio dynamics Monitoring customer behavior

Management Commentary

  • “We still have work ahead of us, but we have a clear vision of what we need to do to optimize our unique and advantaged assets... focus on improving the cash generation capability across our platform and reducing our absolute levels of indebtedness...” — CEO Ed Dowling .
  • “My goal... is to gear the company such that it generates free cash flow even in mild winters, strong free cash flow in normal winters and outstanding free cash flow in strong winters.” — CEO Ed Dowling .
  • “Despite the significant volume declines... absolute operating earnings and adjusted EBITDA [Salt] were only down 4% and 1%, respectively... adjusted EBITDA margin increased to a little over 25%... adjusted EBITDA per ton... increased 20% to $24.50 [FY2024].” — CFO Jeff Cathey .
  • “Total capital expenditures for the company in fiscal 2025 are expected to be... $100–$110 million... scheduled... to allow scaling back... in the event of a mild winter.” — CFO Jeff Cathey .

Q&A Highlights

  • Salt margins/2025 contraction: 2025 Salt EBITDA margins guided lower primarily due to Goderich curtailment driving higher cost of inventory; normalization in 2026 depends on winter and production decisions .
  • Sales-to-commitment ratio bridge: Despite commitments down ~9%, expected sales volumes can be up ~9% based on historical sales-to-commitment ratios, including recent weak winters; focus remains on value over volume .
  • Fortress outlook: Alternate non-MgCl formulation under development and consideration; timing with USFS remains uncertain; guidance excludes potential Fortress revenue .
  • Free cash flow and taxes: Company anticipates FY2025 free cash flow at guidance midpoints; effective tax rate appears nonsensical due to mix—U.S. book losses offset by foreign income .
  • Winter seasonality shift: Discussion of possible shift of winter activity later in the season (more in calendar Q1/Q2), which impacts prefill behavior; monitoring data and customer communications .

Estimates Context

  • S&P Global (Capital IQ) Wall Street consensus for CMP’s Q4 2024 revenue and EPS was unavailable at time of analysis due to system limit errors; as a result, beat/miss vs consensus cannot be assessed. Values intended for estimates comparisons were not retrieved (S&P Global).

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Salt pricing/mix remains resilient; price per ton increased despite volume weakness, supporting margins through weather cycles—watch early winter severity and prefill signals for near-term sentiment .
  • FY2025 playbook is about cash: inventory drawdowns, flexible production (Goderich curtailment), capex pacing, and a targeted debt stack refinance to gain covenant flexibility—execution is a catalyst .
  • Plant Nutrition is a work-in-progress; volumes are normalizing, but pricing pressure persists; pond restoration and KCl supplementation should lower all-in costs over time—monitor cost trajectory and SOP pricing .
  • Fortress remains option value; negotiations continue on non-MgCl product; guidance prudently excludes revenue—any USFS contract would be incremental upside .
  • Balance sheet and liquidity are adequate within covenants (net leverage 4.9x, $189.9M liquidity), but deleveraging remains strategic priority—winter outcomes and working capital release are key .
  • Near-term trading implications: stock likely to react to winter weather data and bid-season commentary (prices ~2% down, commitments ~9% down), plus updates on refinancing and cost projects .
  • Medium-term thesis: advantaged Salt assets and structural efficiency projects (Goderich mill relocation, flexible ops) position CMP to expand margins and free cash flow across weather scenarios if execution continues .